Pressure Mounting on MCI as States Oppose NEET

Recent developments with respect to the newly proposed common medical entrance test for MBBS and BDS courses (NEET UG) by MCI indicated the pressure that is mounting; as days are progressing many States are trying to put pressure through their respective state governments. Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamilnadu & Jammu Kashmir secured exception from NEET UG; the latest being Karnataka which got a stay from the high court objecting NEET UG in 2012.

In Ahmedabad parents are pressurizing the state government to cancel NEET UG in 2012, West Bengal too will take a decision after listening to the stake holders (parents, students & MCI views). Medical Council of India is cornered because they have no defense their objection to allow regional languages is the main cause of concern or loop hole that states are pointing at. Syllabus which has been set to favor CBSE students is another reason, one can’t suddenly make a change to the system in a go.

As per latest news, Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan has requested the center to exempt Maharashtra from NEET UG this year stating indifference in syllabus compared to state boards and timing of the announcement.

MCI should allow time for the state boards to revamp the curriculum to make it inline with the CBSE boards. States are planning curriculum which can keep their students par with central board students who have a rigorous curriculum as compared to state board students. Is it time for MCI to finally say that term ‘Postponed’? Do share your thoughts!

You are reading this article on blog.careermitra.com, stay tuned for career & education news!

83 thoughts on “Pressure Mounting on MCI as States Oppose NEET”

  1. we have no problem with NEET, par problem ye hai ki hume NEET ke bare me late inform kiya tha isliye hum NEET ke liye proper studies nahi kar paye hai..

  2. @Gautham,
    Can U tell me the basic fundamental difference being taught in Orissa ,Himachal, Punjab, UP,Bihar , CBSE on (I) Newton” Law of motion(2) Faraday’s law(3) Carnot cycle(4) Wave propagation or any topic? The basic principal does does not differ , only differs its application which changes from perception of student and not the board.

    1. @ bk gupta ap only physics ki bat q karte ho total syl. ki bat karo jisse ap jan jaoge k upboard aur cbse k syl. me 40% diff. hai padhiye
      FOR ZOOLOGY——-RAMESH GUPTA
      FOR BOTANY———M.P.KAUSHIK
      FOR CHEM. ———-K. N. SHARMA
      FOR PHYSICS——–KUMAR MITTAL

  3. @kiri,
    How do U know that rural area students are not aware about NEET and they are preparing about state PMT? It is a mockery that you know that rural area students are preparing for State PMT and you are not telling them. Why U are silent kiri? Is something hidden in your agenda?I am from rural area and even big fat daddy’s kins are aware about Pvt medical colleges. How? I think NEET is being opposed by particular segment of society (though very small in quantity but effective in resource terms) whose interests are on the stake. NEET will bring a revolutionary change in corruption ridden medical education in India on one hand but on other hand I am sure that it will never happen until and unless thousands of Anna come on the road to end this mafia ridden medical education.

    1. @BKG,

      I am happy that after a many postings of mine addressed to you there is a response!!!.I think you are one of few exceptions.Who am i to tell rural guys.Is it not responsibility of MCI AND the government to have reaching out to these people and that too much earlier?.Even today where is the notification?.Do not make fool of yourself ?.If you are from village,pl inform all there and then start informing others in other villages.
      My dear i am not against NEET BUT THE WAY IT IS BEING FORCED ON US FOR BENIFITTING CBSE GUYS BY REDUCING COMPETITION.If you are fond of only NEET then wait till 2014.

    1. @Kiri.
      Yes, I am few exceptions. Further, I am also fond of NEET. Why to wait till 2014 when there is little light at the end of tunnel in 2012? I am fed up by hearing that CBSE guys are in advantageous stage. Mr Kiri, Can U tell me How? Mere drum beating on the issues like shortage of time, different syllabus , language problem are the issues not in the national interest. Cetrtainly thes issues relate with “Swiss” Interest. I am ready to discuss each topic of syllabus of your board and CBSE. Mr. Kiri Why U are not making any issues on syllabus of pvt medical colleges? Why U are silent on this? Are U aware with admission system of BVP, DY patil, Krishna karad, HIHT, MP DMAT, AMUPDMC, SUMNDEEP , Kalinga etc. ? Can U tell me they are fair? I believe in the theory of survial of the fittest. Mr Kiri I am 99% Confident that NEET will never happen in India untill and unless roots are thrown out. You know better than me where the roots are? Issues are being raised for the sake of raising the issues as montery interest of education mafia is on stake.

      1. @BKG,

        I expected this mugged up answer only from you.But you have conveniently forgotten responding to my comment reg.reaching out to the students from rural area.

        I am still firm on my opinion that NEET is being forced in 2012 to reduce competition for CBSE.Period…

  4. IMPLEMENTATION OF NEET THIS YEAR IS IDIOTIC ACTION. THE PEOPLE WHO ARE POSTING THEIR COMMENT HERE SHOULD KNOW HOW TO BRING THE CHANGES IN THE EXISTING SYSTEM OF EDUCATION, THEN ONLY THEY SHOULD POST THEIR COMMENT. EDUCATION SYSTEM STARTS FROM ITS ACCADEMIC YEAR AND WHAT EVER CHANGES THE STATE OR CENTERE SHOULD BRING THE CHANGES IN THE BEGINING OF THE ACCADEMIC YEAR THATS ALL. IF ANY WANTS FAVOUR OUT OF THIS THEIR MIND MAY BE POLLUTED.

  5. See Friends here curruption is not important. Main problem is study of the student during two years period 11th Class and 12th Class. According to that only the entrance should be there. The action of MCI is idiotic when they have issued the notification in the middle of the year that in November when all the junior colleges have completed their syllabus. Where they have slept for the complete year. Who ever starts changes in the education system that will be from the beigining of the accademic year. If this much also MCI do not know means they are useless in the country.

    1. NEET must be implemented from 2012 and equal opportunity should be given to all students of the country. samay aa gaya hai ki ab india me es tarah ke faisely me PVT college dalal, thikedar ki baat nahi suna jaye. ye langra langra ke chalne ka aadat govt. ko chhodna chahiye. NEET 2012 ko lagu hone me hi MCI ki ijjat hai.

      1. @ Raj,

        Pl do not make contradictory comments.On one side you are saying equal opportunity to be given to all students and on other side you are advocating NEET in 2012.Where is equality? Many students from rural area are not even aware of something called NEET and they are still preparing for state entrance test.

        1. sc ka kya faisela aaya hai kuchh pata hai???????mujhe v nahi. ab to hamlogo ka5 dhyan udhar hi hai. sarelog hai neet taraf aur leader log apna profit taraf.

  6. NEET must implement from 2012, nahi to next year bhi ye kamine kutte haramkhor(all politician and private college owners who are apposing NEET) koi naya idea nikalkar NEET ko talne ki koshish karenge, ye log bhi bahot shane hai saale saalbhar to kuch nahi karenge lekin exam ke notification ke time par hi apni taang adate hai, last year bhi yahi hua tha, court me case dalte hai judges ke muh me paisa thuskar aur student ke emotions ki aad me stay order le lete hai, ab jab tak court ka koi faisla hoga tabtak 1-2 mahine nikal jayenge fir kahenge ab to time bahut kam bacha hai isliye exam next year hi hona chahiye….bahut bade bundlebaaz hai sale!!!!!

  7. GUYS THOUGH NEET IS A GOOD DECISION BUT I AM SHOCKED TO SEE MOST CORRUPT STATES BEING EXEMPTED……… THIS HAS FORCED ME TO CHANGE SIDES BECAUSE WHY SHOULD MY STATE BEAR FOR THE DOINGS OF THESE IDIOTIC STATES ………….. I WANT MY STATE PMT TO TAKE PLACE ………

  8. yes……….charo taraf lut hi lut chal raha hai. kanoonka to na aankh hai na pair. bhai politician aur pvt college thikedar ke bich bichar bimarse pe tay hota hai ki NEET hona nahi hai. achha hota ki NEET 2012 se hi laagu hota. varna next yer v yahi phalatu baate hogi

  9. Source: The Sangai Express

    Imphal, December 02 2011: State Medical Directorate has informed the intending candidates for nomination to Manipur MBBS/BDS seats for the academic session 2012-2013 to appear in the NEET 2012 to be conducted by CBSE in May next year.

    Detailed information can be seen on the websites: http://www.cbse.gov.in and http://www.aipmt.inc.in.

    There will be no separate Manipur MBBS/BDS entrance examination 2012, said a press release.

  10. is desh ka kuch nahi ho sakta bhai logo, yaha har taraf loot machi hai, lootne wale sansad me lootne ke tariko par bahas me busy hai, ab to neet cancel hi samjho, mera sabhi students se nivedan hai ki sabhi apne apne state pmt aur aipmt ki taiyari kare next year hum sabhi fir se isi matter par isi jagah bahas karenge ….till than good bye!!!!!

  11. i think NEET should be there in 2012 because if they postpone this year, then it is difficult to proceed
    in 2013, again some other problems will arise. So, now this is the right time to conduct NEET and another thing is four states like Tamilnadu, Andhra pradesh and some states are exempted from NEET exam, the question arises whether they will give 15 % seats to central pool quota or not ?

    1. dude u need to stop thinking ………..
      neet has been ordered by sc so it will be implemented . only issue is time. many states in india want it in 2014 so what is wrong in it …………………

    1. are bhai ye saare ka saara drama lagta hai. saare pvt college ka neta k saath mgmt hota hai. MCI KO SC COURT ME APPROACH KAR 2012 SE HI NEET LAAGU KRNA CHAHIYE

  12. Why should MCI postpone NEET?? For the sake of few opposing States, there is no need for NEET to be postponed. All the opposing States were heard by Supreme Court and they were privy to the decision taken by Supreme Court. I feel, its all due to politics and lobbying by Private medical colleges trying to put spokes into the proceedings.

    As per National Education Policy announced 3 years back, States were suppose to reform their education and make it on par with CBSE standard. All these opposing States did not do anything in this matter and were caught unaware when NEET was announced and a section of students began opposing because of their apprehension in adopting the change. Whose fault it is ? Is it MCI’s fault?? Even if we give 2 years lay-off, I am sure the situation will not change much after 2 years. That is the curse of Indian system. Unless good systems are implemented immdly, what may come, it is not possible to do it in a planned manner in this country.

    MCI is doing the right thing in approaching the Supreme court which mooted NEET first. Let the court decide which ever is right under the circumstances. I sincerely hope the judges are not corrupt.

    1. one question
      which planet are u from .
      what ever u have written shows mistakes commited by politicians no matter state or centre but why should students get punished. i sometime feel are u some mci agent who have come here top brainwash people on this forum . u are talking about planned manner but is neet being conducted in planned manner . no , it is being forced on students . stop criticising this country .

      WHY DID NOT MCI GO TO SC WHEN STATES WERE APPEALING . SUCH IDIOTIC MOVES OF MCI WILL ONLY WASTE OUR TIME …………..

      1. jat bhai rise man, tumhe kuch pata nahi hai neet ke bare me aur iske rules ke bare me, pahle iske bare me jano fir baat karna i am sure after that u’ll support mr dinesh, neet sare student ke fyde ka sauda hai, chahe neet bilingual ho ya syllabus me difference ho still its a good move, isse kisi state ka haq nahi marega, ye neta logo ko sirf paiso se matlab hai ye sirf hum students ke emotions ko use kar rahe hai isliye neet ki sirf wahi bate bahar aa rahi hai jise pahli baar sunne me students uske against ho jata hai…

        1. abe dhakkan . mujhe neet ke bare mein sab pata hai tabhi isko oppose kar raha hoon . neet is a good move but only i it is implemented in right time. mujhe yeh bata neet mein yeh neta ki batein kaha se aa gayi ………………..

          1. abe jhandoo balm tujhe pata hai india me kitne private medical college hai aur kitne in opposing states me hai (more than 120 out of 180), gujrat me sare bade(rich) baap oppose kar rahe hai, 120 colleges me se 90% colleges me in politician ka directly or indirectly paisa laga hua hai agar tujhe ye nahi pata to tere se bada dhakkan koi nahi hai, time ki baat kare to agar tu padne wala hai to neet exam nikaal lega(agar tu private medical college ke chakkar me nahi hai to) syllabus me itna difference nahi hai ke tu cover nahi kar paye aur rahi baat language ki to tu yaha jo angreji me bakbak kar raha hai wo kafi hai neet ke liye, neet ko conduct karne ka jo primary reason hai wo hai corruption in private medical college…

            samjhe jaat bhai

          2. i am from karnataka still i am favouring neet because i have seen with my own eyes “rich baaps” were betting for mbbs seats in a private medical college of a cabinet minister sitting in delhi, u must compare karnataka and neet syllabus how much difference is there, still i want neet why? its not only about me but for all students. i have another example, in indore(M.P.) there is a medical college named Shree Aurobindo Institute of Medical Sciences, my friend studying there, do u know who’s college is this? DIGVIJAY SINGH, congress( Ex CM of MP and presently attacking on anna and baba ramdev), why he needed to invest in a medical college ???

      2. Great !!!you have expressed opinion of majority of students in best and easiest possible way.But will be understood by only those who have not shut eyes and ears to the plight of majority and who are not MCI agents and most important -who are not selfish.

  13. मेडिकल कॉमन एंट्रेंस टेस्ट का मामला टला

    प्रदीप सुरीनत्ननई दिल्ली

    एमबीबीएस के लिए 2012 से कॉमन एंट्रेंस टेस्ट (सीईटी) लागू करने पर ब्रेक लग सकता है। केंद्रीय स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय अगले शिक्षा सत्र से सीईटी लागू करने में आ रही समस्याओं को देखते हुए इसे एक साल टालने की योजना बना रही है। इस बाबत मंत्रालय ने कानून मंत्रालय को पत्र लिख कर सलाह मांगी है। पिछले महीने मेडिकल काउंसिल ऑफ इंडिया (एमसीआई) ने घोषणा की थी कि देश के सभी मेडिकल कॉलेजों में एमबीबीएस डिग्री के लिए मई, 2012 में सीईटी की परीक्षा आयोजित की जाएगी। पोस्ट ग्रेजुएट मेडिकल परीक्षा के लिए एक प्रवेश परीक्षा अगले साल से लागू करवाने पर एमसीआई पहले ही असमर्थता जता चुकी है।

    स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय के सूत्रों का कहना है कि मेडिकल में दाखिले के लिए एक प्रवेश परीक्षा पर तमिलनाडु, आंध्र प्रदेश, कर्नाटक, महाराष्ट्र और गुजरात की ओर से आधिकारिक रुप से विरोध के बाद आगामी शिक्षा सत्र से लागू करवाना बेतुका कदम लगने लगा है। बहुत जल्द पश्चिम बंगाल की ओर से भी सीईटी में शामिल नहीं होने के लिए आधिकारिक पत्र आने की संभावना है। देश के 85 फीसदी मेडिकल कॉलेजों वाले इन राज्यों के इंकार के बाद स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय ने सीईटी को एक साल के लिए टालने का फैसला किया है। सूत्र ने बताया कि मंत्रालय ने केंद्रीय कानून मंत्रालय को पत्र लिख कर पूछा है कि अगर सीईटी को 2013 के शिक्षा सत्र से लागू करवाया जाए तो क्या सुप्रीम कोर्ट की अवमानना होगी?

    मामले से जुड़े स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय के एक अन्य अधिकारी का कहना है कि सीईटी को सीबीएससी से लागू करवाना और इसमें क्षेत्रीय भाषाओं को शामिल नहीं करना एक और बड़ी चुनौती बनी हुई है। इसके अलावा देश में बड़े पैमाने पर मौजूद निजी मेडिकल कॉलेज भी सीईटी का लगातार विरोध कर रहे हैं।

    अधिकारी का कहना है कि एमसीआई और स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय जब तक इन मुद्दों का समाधान नहीं तलाश लेते, सीईटी को लागू करवाने में का किसी न किसी स्तर पर समस्या आती रहेगी। देश में लगभग 300 मेडिकल कॉलेज हैं जिनमें 30,000 एमबीबीएस की सीटें हैं। इनमें दाखिला लेने के लिए छात्रों को 17 अलग -अलग प्रवेश परीक्षाओं में बैठना पड़ता है। सुप्रीम कोर्ट में एक मामले की सुनवाई के दौरान खुद एमसीआई ने हलफनामा दायर किया था कि देश में सीईटी लागू किया जा सकता है। पिछले कई महीनों से इसे लागू करवाने की सभी कोशिशें नाकाम साबित हो रही है।

  14. Frends…..
    I m big big big big big supporter of neet…..
    But according to current situation mai ye kehne pe majbur ho gaya hu ki
    Mci ki ye chuppi humlogo ko kahi hizra bana ke na chhod de….
    Aise me na to state pmt qualify kar payenge na hi neet aur na hi aipmt……
    Plz mci decide soon and decide permanently…….

    1. good thought, i have doubt now the four states like TAMILNADU, ANDHRAPRADESH AND OTHER STATES have postponed NEET exam, now the question is will they give 15% seats to central pool or not ?

    2. good thought, i have doubt now the four states like TAMILNADU, ANDHRAPRADESH AND OTHER STATES have postponed NEET exam, now the question is will they give 15% seats to central pool or not ?

  15. Where is baba and his undercover agent. They confirmed that aipmt notification will be out on 22 nov. Infact now its a backlash for him & his co as mci is moving sc to uplift the stay orders given by the high courts.

  16. I THINK NEET EXAME MUST BE CONDUCTED ONLY FROM 2012. STATE MAY GIVE GEEV FEEDBACK ON SYLLABUS AND LANGUAGE IF ANY DISCREPANCY. ITS USEFUL FOR STUDENT THAT WILL HAVE HUGE NO. OF SIT APPROX 40000.

    1. DUDE IT IS EVIDENT U ARE NOT AWARE OF NEET ………
      FIRST OF ALL NOV. IS ENDING U ARE STILL STUCK ON SENDING FEEDBACKS …… THEY SHOULD DECLARE AIPMT AND THEN TALK ANYTHING THEY WANT …………..
      THE RESERVATION IS SAME AS THEIR IN AIPMT AND STATE SO U HAVE SAME NO. OF SEATS WITH ONLY ONE CHANCE COMING YOUR WAY …………..

  17. HELLO SRKANT
    CAREER MITRA LOOKS EVEN MORE BEAUTIFULL NOW BUT CAN U MAKE THE BORDERS OF THESE COMMENTS A BIT DARK ………
    I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO OPEN CAREER MITRA FOR ATLEAST 2 DAYS NOW BUT HAVE BEEN UNSUCCESSFULL ….. I DON’T KNOW WHY ?????????
    PLZ LOOK INTO THE MATTER ………….

  18. Instead of requesting SC a way to conduct the exam in 2012, MCI should request postponement of the start of NEET by atleast a few years to enable the student community and the state govts and MCI itself to prepare for it.
    It was a mistake on the part of MCI to think of a Nationwide test like this without educating the stakeholders about NEET. An unified sylabus all over India is a must before implementing this.
    I dont think anyone is againt NEET.But everone is telliing to give sufficient time for the preparation like unified sylabus from 11th std atleast and a cooling time to adjust to the new system and proper planning from the MCI / the govts.
    Any way the problem of attending multiple exam will worsen as the candidate has to appear for neet for mbbs/bds and all other entrance exams forBHMS,BAMS ,vetenary, Agriculture etc. which was not the case before. Most the preveous entrance tests were common for mbbs and other allied courses.
    Moreover if NEET is introduced now the poor students in the villages especially those in economically and socially reserved will be really affected as most of them are till now not even heard of a plan for NEET.In such a situation if NEET introduced now even the reserved seats will be taken by rich candidates of those community living in town following CBSE sylabus and those in villages in vernacular medium in state sylabus will be badly effected.
    MCI and some others with vested interest is not trying to solve the basic issue and pointing fingers to some state GOVTs and private colleges to fool the general public without doing their homework.
    In a nutshell MCI should request SC to allow them to plan the NEET properly and introduce first Super Speciality, then PG and last UG.

  19. Instead of requesting SC a way to conduct the exam in 2012, MCI should request postponement of the start of NEET by atleast a few years to enable the student community and the state govts and MCI itself to prepare for it.
    It was a mistake on the part of MCI to think of a Nationwide test like this without educating the stakeholders about NEET. An unified sylabus all over India is a must before implementing this.
    I dont think anyone is againt NEET.But everone is telliing to give sufficient time for the preparation like unified sylabus from 11th std atleast and a cooling time to adjust to the new system and proper planning from the MCI and the govts.
    Any way the problem of attending multiple exam will worsen as the candidate has to appear for neet for mbbs/bds and all other entrance exams forBHMS,BAMS ,vetenary, Agriculture etc. which was not the case before. Most the preveous entrance tests were common for mbbs and other allied courses.
    Moreover if NEET is introduced now the poor students in the villages especially those in economically and socially reserved will be really affected as most of them are till now not even heard of a plan for NEET.In such a situation if NEET introduced now even the reserved seats will be taken by rich candidates of those community living in town following CBSE sylabus and those in villages in vernacular medium in state sylabus will be badly effected.
    MCI and some others with vested interest is not trying to solve the basic issue and pointing fingers to some state GOVTs and private colleges to fool the general public without doing their homework.
    In a nutshell MCI should request SC to allow them to plan the NEET properly and introduce first Super Speciality, then PG and last UG.

  20. MCI to checkmate states in SC
    Tags: Education, medical

    The MCI and the Karnataka government have been at
    loggerheads over implementing the NEET-UG -DC The confusion surrounding the
    implementation of the National
    Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET)-
    Under Graduate (UG) from the
    academic year 2012-13, has taken a
    new twist with the Medical Council of India (MCI) planning to approach
    the Supreme Court seeking its help
    to resolve the crisis. Several State governments, including
    Karnataka, and many private
    medical colleges, are vehemently
    opposing the implementation of
    NEET-UG from this year. The
    Karnataka High Court has issued a stay order in this regard. MCI will take a final decision on
    conducting the NEET-UG at a meeting of its Board of Governors on
    Friday. According to MCI officials, private colleges and deemed-to-be
    universities are opposing the NEET-UG because they know that
    once the common entrance test is implemented, they can’t play
    around with the admissions process as they have been doing so
    far. “Presently, impersonation is very common in most admission tests
    conducted by private institutes/consortiums. This type of
    malpractice generates huge revenue for the managements. Most
    of the admission tests lack transparency. So, everyone is opposing
    the MCI’s decision. Unfortunately, some State governments have
    also joined hands with them,” said a senior MCI officer. “One of the complaints of the Karnataka government is that the
    NEET-UG syllabus is not covered in the State curriculum and it may
    create problems for students from the State. But the State
    government was silent when we asked for feedback on the draft
    syllabus,” the officer added. When contacted, one of the governors
    of the MCI, Prof. K. Mohandas, confirmed that the council will move the Supreme Court seeking its guidance over implementation of
    NEET-UG from this academic year. “Even though many State High Courts have issued stay orders, as
    of now there is no change in our decision,” he said. “It is the Supreme Court that has directed us to conduct this single
    national-level test. The Board of Governors of MCI will meet on
    Friday in New Delhi to discuss the issue. We will approach the
    Supreme Court seeking relief from stay orders issued by several
    State High Courts,” Prof Mohandas said.

  21. @ sameer dudhe…
    Ya dude neet is important for country like india…
    The main reason was to reduce corruption…
    Neet is very helpful for the students whose state pmt pattern is diffrnt from aipmt and cbse syllabus…
    Neet syllabus is the most standard syllabus ever taught in india…
    If students from these states want to prepare for aiims, jipmer then they have to read two diffrnt syllabus at the same time and also they have to prepare themslvs for two diffrnt exam patterns…
    Neet ensures uniformity all over india…
    Dude mci ppl are very responsible and expernced persons…
    We cant say this so easily that mci is wrong…
    This decison was from all the six members of mci and not from single person…

    1. agree
      but jin states mein corruption hai woh to exempt ho rahe hain ……
      yaar cbse ka ek fayda yeh hai ki woh state ko bhi cover karwata hai , jo cbse ka hai woh state bhi de sakta hai par state wale bichare state hi de sakte hain…….
      syllabus is very standard but give time to students to come to its level ….
      aroun 13 00 000 medical aspirants are present in india and only 80 000 – 100000 give aiims and jipmer exam ………
      when education is not uniform then how neet can be beneficial . base to banao yaar building baad mein khadi karna ……..
      mci ka toh naam mat lo . sirf khana jante hain . unke sare scams hi bata dete hai n . agar responsible hote toh yeh situation kabhi aati hi nahi ….

      jai hind

    2. agree
      but jin states mein corruption hai woh to exempt ho rahe hain ……
      yaar cbse ka ek fayda yeh hai ki woh state ko bhi cover karwata hai , jo cbse ka hai woh state bhi de sakta hai par state wale bichare state hi de sakte hain…….
      syllabus is very standard but give time to students to come to its level ….
      aroun 13 00 000 medical aspirants are present in india and only 80 000 – 100000 give aiims and jipmer exam ………
      when education is not uniform then how neet can be beneficial . base to banao yaar building baad mein khadi karna ……..
      mci ka toh naam mat lo . sirf khana jante hain . unke sare scams hi bata dete hai n . agar responsible hote toh yeh situation kabhi aati hi nahi ….

      jai hind

  22. @kumar
    if all states opposing get exemption then no way can neet take place . other states will also start opposing . any how why hasn’t neet notification come up yet ………

  23. neet cancel ho gaya kya . november khatam hone ko aya hai ab to nahi lagta kianeet ho sakta hai . aipmt forms kab tak aayenge .

  24. bhaiyon neet m bhi toh 85% seats state k bachoon k liye reserve rahenge dikkat sirf un state govt ko ho rha h jinke pvt medical college se moti kamai ati h so favour neet its right choice baby

    1. when reservation is same then why to have neet ……… this us the portion which is troubling state students …………. why neet when nothing is changing …………..

  25. bhaiyon state govts neet ke bare m galat afwah uda rahe h bcoz unka pvt college wala kamai bandh ho jayega isliye all students should support neet

  26. neet se sabka fayda h no. of seats badh jayenge pre n mains ka jhanjhat khatm ho jayega n garib logon ko form ka paisa bhi bach jayega

    1. let me get this straight …… you are saying that the change is being brought so that instead of 3 exams people could fill only 3 exams …….. no. of seats also look the same ….. is this the reason to trouble the students ………. i am cbse student but i also don’t feel the need of neet ………..

      did i miss any point ….. are their any other uses ………..

  27. NEET-UG should not be postponed for the year 2012 because many of students have started preparing according to the syllabus of NEET-UG as provided by mci

  28. whf …… why hasn’t aipmt notificatin come up yet …….. itne states to exempt karwa ke kya khak neet hoga ……. sharam ani chhiye mci ko ……

  29. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/Breather-for-aspiring-medical-students/articleshow/10837519.cms

    A source in the Medical Council of India (MCI), which had suggested the idea of a common entrance test for medical, conceded that several states, like Tamil Nadu, Maharastra and Karnataka, are also resisting CET on different issues, at least for this year. “The health ministry is consulting with the law ministry and they will see if these states can be exempted from introducing CET for some more time,” said the source.

    1. KUMAR BHAI AIPMT SE TO 2 HI STATE EXEMPT THE PAR NEET SE TO KAM SE KAM 6-7 STATE EXEMPTION MANG RAHE HAIN , AISE MEIN KYA NEET HO SAKTA HAI ……. IN STATES MEIN HI TO SABSE JYADA CORRUPTION HAI …… IN STATES KE PVT. COLLEGES KA KYA HOGA … KYA HUM UNKE LIYE COMPETE KAR PAYENGE ………
      PLZ IF ANYONE KNOWS PLZ REPLY ……..

      1. Game Bhai
        Pehle apne bare me socho doosre state ke student ki chinta chhodo yeh neet ki talwar north en state per jaroor latki hui hai or ham tum north se hai.

        Meri bat ka biswas karo agar neet nahi hona hota to ab tak AIPMT ka notification jaroor aa jata so let us discuss about study.

        1. kumar bro this cannot be possible that so many states are exempted and still neet takes place .
          i am from uttrakhand and came to know about neet a week ago . people are still not aware of neet . how can it be conducted without any prior warning .
          their has been news that cbse will be bringing out aipmt notification very soon …..

        2. kumar bhai kahin south india se toh nahi ho ……
          dusre states jo corrupt hain woh chut jayenge aur baki phas jayenge huh …..

          aipmt ka notification ane wala hai ………
          aur waise bhi ager neet hona hota toh neet ka notification ab tak aa chuka hota

          1. Hello chak jawana
            Nahi maine U.P. Se hoo but 12th delhi se kiya hai. basicaliy that comment was only for game changer u guys taken wrongly.

      2. Game Bhai
        Pehle apne bare me socho doosre state ke student ki chinta chhodo yeh neet ki talwar northen state per jaroor latki hui hai or ham tum north se hai.

        Meri bat ka biswas karo agar neet nahi hona hota to ab tak AIPMT ka notification jaroor aa jata so let us discuss about study.

  30. There is only one way for reducing the pressure on MCI. Derecognise Pvt medical collges. Automatically, things will settle down. I know Gujarat , only 300 resourcefull parents(Can pay the malai income to Pvt Medical college)/Agents/brokers gathered to oppose NEET. These few persons can not represent the sentiments of 6 Cr Gujarati.

      1. In West Bengal two private cMedical Colleges are reported to have been existing though one of them- the famous Laxman Seth Medical College at Haldia have not yet been able to manage the boss in the states by offering huge money to obtain formal permission. These Medical colleges are very very interested to avoid NEET as they will not be able to raise crores of money for their personal gain. This year, I personally received phone calls from one of my friends, whose daughter has not been able to crack WBJEE(Med) Exam, that she has got admitted at the Medical College at Haldia with the help of huge money. I doubt how many like this under merited syudents are getting admitted in the Pvt Medical colleges only beacuse their parents are resonavly wealthy. Morever, what service they will offer to the society when they themselves do not have the capacity to get academic execellence. NEET is must for a country like ours but befor that MCI shouldadvise the concerned Govts to introduce uniform Syllabus and ensure that question papers are published in regeional languages at least for the years.

    1. Hi Srikanth,
      Something seems to be drastically wrong with system at your end.I am taking ages to access your blogs and if at all I do,I am not able to submit my comments.Pl.arrange to rectify the problem at the earliest.Thanks.

      1. Hi Vijay, I agree with you; we are fixing this and improving our infrastructure to accommodate more users. Thanks for your patience and due apologies for the inconvenience caused.

    2. had hai yaar , har commenta mein ek hi baat likhte ho ………
      mujhe ek cheez bata , jab 1 aadmi ke case neet jaisa change karwa diya to 300 to phir bhi bahut hain … ab tum kaho ge ki 1 nahi the aur bhi the jyada se jyada 10 laga lo …….. yeh india hai yahan koi kashat nahi uthana chahta hai …….. i salute these people for coming out and oppose ……….. yeh batao ki 6 cr mein se kitne medical aspirants honge …….. mushkil se 30 -35 000 , in mein kise neet ke bare mein pata hoga , aur jinhe pata hoga un mein se to jyada tar log ghar me so rahe honge yeh soch kar ki humare bache kar lenge …….

      sala idhar neet supporters ke comment pad kar lagta hai ki tumhe neet ke bare mein kuch pata hi nahi …………

  31. Today wbjeeb chairman said that since no notification from MCI still have not come,they will take step withing few days to announce WBJEE soon.

  32. NEET CAN NOT DEFINATELY TAKE PLACE IN 2012 . THE POST ITSELF SHOWS WHY . BUT CAN ANYONE TELL ME WHY SOME PEOPLE HERE ARE SUPPORTING NEET . IT IS SURPRISING TO SEE SUPPORTERS AFTER ALL THIS OPPOSITION . BUT AM I MISSING OUT ON SOMETHING . CAN ANYONE TELL ME THE BENEFITS OF NEET ……

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Captcha * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.