Supreme Court Unhappy On NEET Postponement

neet ugEarlier The Medical Council of India (MCI) has filed an affidavit in Supreme Court stating it can’t go ahead with NEET UG next year; citing reasons as indifference with majority of states (AP, Karnataka, West Bengal, Tamilnadu, Maharashtra etc).

A Bench of Justices H.L. Dattu and C.K. Prasad after reviewing the petition has reportedly expressed dissatisfaction on postponing NEET UG. The apex court has questioned the petitioners as why they are backing the decision having sought permission to conduct common medical entrance test months ago. The court wasn’t keen to support the petitioners and said we are not part with the decision, ‘you can do what ever you want’.

The court didn’t pass any order and insisted the petitioners to with draw it’s application; the court indicated not to intervene ‘SC’ in this regard.

NEET UG is postponed to next year; MCI will face the challenge of convincing these opposing states for next year’s NEET UG. Though few states have agreed to participate from 2013; certain states (Andhra Pradesh) are asking for a 2 years exception. The whole story might again come up, what are your views!

Links to articles

http://www.thehindu.com/

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/

You are reading this article on blog.careermitra.com, stay tuned for career & education news!

94 comments on “Supreme Court Unhappy On NEET Postponement

  1. DON.N N N N ........ says:

    for neet support
    Neet supports अरे पागलो neet का इंतज़ार करते करते
    तुम्हारा बुढापा आ जायेगा लेकिन neet
    कभी भी नहीं हो सकेगी , तुम डाक्टर बनने का सपना देखना बंद कर
    दो क्योंकि तुम्हारी ओकात चपरासी बनने तक
    कि bhi नहीं हैं . तुम वही करो जो तुम्हारा बाप करता हैं . तुमने क्या सोचा था कि neet हो जायेगा और फ़ोकट मे
    हि
    मेडिकल कोलेज मे घुस जायेगे .लेकिन तुम जेसे
    गधो को हम कभी भी मेडिकल कोलेज मे नहीं घूसने
    देंगे , because we have power of money.

    • saxena says:

      If NEET is implemented in such a haste , only coaching centers will make lot of money.Again only the rich will be benefited.
      For the sake of the bright and poor students , who can not afford any costly coaching classes, CBSE AIPMT , other state PMT etc should continue for the timebeing.this will defenitely assist the bright students from poor families in the villages , who were preparing for this type of exams for the last many years without the assistance of the expensive coaching classes.

      CBSE, MCI, & the Govt should introduce NEET with proper preparations after a couple of years which will be helpful to the complte student community whether rich or poor , cbse or stateboard,urban or village, english or vernacular etc. etc.

  2. Dr. Rajesh Nagarwal says:

    Perhaps the chapter of neet-ug 2012 has been over by the worst politician only for vote bank. Now their next step will be for mbbs study in gujrati, marathi & so many indian language. and INDIA KE SABHEE COURT STAY BHEE ISSUE KAR DENGE. ” ONLY GOD CAN SAVE THIS COUNTRY.”

  3. Dr. Rajesh Nagarwal says:

    perhaps the chapter of neet-ug 2012 has been over by worst politician. Their next step will be for mbbs study in gujrati, marathi & so many indian language.” Only God can save this Country.’

  4. Rahul says:

    It seems that everyone except me has become serious in their work!!!oh God when would it be my turn?!!or otherwise I will have to wait till january end of the next year for final official call on medical entrance exam!!!

  5. Rock says:

    Don knw wat da hel is goin on in our country…..if they can’t take any final decision ..wat are they doin for …let d student tk final decision..

  6. the game changer says:

    am again back with another bang ………

    Amendment to pave way for holding NEET from 2013
    WEDNESDAY, 21 DECEMBER 2011 23:11 ARCHANA JYOTI | NEW DELHI HITS: 26
    User Rating: / 0
    PoorBest
    Determined to postpone the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) 2012 for medical graduates by a year, the Health Ministry is seeking amendment to a notification that would legally pave way for holding the test from 2013.

    The move comes in the wake of the Supreme Court’s recent refusal to accept its demand to defer conducting of the NEET, scheduled for May 13, 2012 for the next academic session of 2013-14.

    “Since the apex court has refused to intervene in the matter, now we have no option but to amend the notification (dated December 21, 2010) to postpone the examination date for May 2013. The Medical Council of India (MCI) has already sent a proposal in this regard to the Health Ministry for its approval,” sources told The Pioneer.

    However, the case has brought to the fore the ineffectiveness of the present Board of Governors (BOG) of the MCI, headed by Dr KK Talwar, which remained a mute spectator in the whole episode. In fact, it acted as desired by the Health Ministry, which was opposed to NEET from the day it was conceived in 2010 by the MCI BOG led by Dr SK Sarin.

    Sources said, the current BOG could have appealed the Court to allow it to hold the NEET in the non-objecting states. “The CBSE was ready to hold the examination. Conducting it in some states would have given the Council an idea about the logistics as well as its efficacy.”

    Last year, the MCI had submitted before the court that the notification had been approved by the Centre as early as in August 2010, a claim contested by the Health Ministry.

    Clearly under pressure from the Ministry, the MCI made a U-turn in the court recently saying that with many States such as Goa and Maharashtra opposing the national-level common entrance test at under-graduate and post graduate levels, it is not in a position to implement it from 2012-13.

  7. Rahul says:

    @GAME C…,Hello friend do u have any latest info regarding today’s hearing on NEET in Bombay High Court..plz. Share with us..

  8. MUNNA BHAI MBBS says:

    cbse just follow the instruction released by government. previously when gov was agary for holding neet, directed cbse to arrange the neet. so cbse went to suprem court and wanted permission for holing neet in 2012 but on the same day mci and gov had filled a application for postponment of neet in 2012. so suprem court had hold the deciso for final hearing on 10 jan 2012. after that gov announced that they are not going to holding n neet in 2012 so health minister release a press note for that. and allowing every state to hold their own exam and also directed cbse to hold aipmt 2012 not neet.. marta bechara kya na karta.. cbse ne aipmt ka notification jari kar diya. par avi v uska application for holding neet in 2012 me suprem court me pending pada hua hai… ab suprem court kya karta hai ye to woqt hi batayega…

  9. Prince says:

    today i called aipmt office..
    I asked about the possibility of aipmt or neet in 2012..
    She told me that cbse has yet not decided about the exam to be conducted in 2012…
    She told me that cbse is waiting for sc decison on 10th jan..
    “Decison would come out after 1st week of jan” she added…
    If u dont belive then call@01122509259

    • RISE OF JATT says:

      meri to kuch samaj nahi aa raha hai …… main tabse cbse aur mci se contact karne kli koshis kar raha hoon par lagta hi nahi hai ………..

  10. purna says:

    wbjee notification has been published in their official website, http://wbjeeb.in/pdf2011/2012/JEM_Notice2012.pdf.

  11. the game changer says:

    LADIES AND GENTLEMAN AM BACK WITH A BANG …….. I FEEL PROUD TO ANNOUNCE THE FOLLOWING :

    National med exam from 2013-14: MCI
    Rosy Sequeira, TNN | Dec 20, 2011, 01.29AM IST

    Article
    Comments

    Read More:The National|NEET|Medical Council Of India|Justice Dhananjay Chandrachud|Cbse

    0

    MUMBAI: The Medical Council of India (MCI) on Monday told the Bombay High Court that it would not implement the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) for the academic year 2012-13, but would do so the following year.

    NEET is a single admission process for MBBS and post-graduate medical courses throughout the country. A division bench of Justice Dhananjay Chandrachud and Justice Amjad Sayed were hearing petitions filed by the state government, the Association of Medical Colleges (AMC) and students. They challenged MCI’s notifications of December 21, 2010 and November 11, 2011, prescribing and finalising the syllabus for NEET.

    AMC’s advocate informed the court that on December 8, 2011, the Aurangabad bench had stayed the exams. She said three other high courts (Madras, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka) in the country have also stayed NEET. “The Aurangabad bench is of the opinion that the syllabus is based on CBSE,” she said.

    The MCI advocate submitted that NEET would be implemented not for academic year 2012-13 but for 2013-14. The judges said that in view of MCI’s statement, the students would not be under undue stress. “They will get enough time to prepare themselves,” said Justice Chandrachud.

    Advocate Ashutosh Kumbhakoni, appearing for some students, said, “If they are not implementing NEET, then the whole issue gets resolved.” He urged the court to permit DMER to proceed with preparations for holding the Common Entrance Test.

    The judges directed the MCI to put its say in an affidavit and posted the hearing for December 21.

    • GURU says:

      game bhai

      hamare yaha up kanpur me 19 DEC. 2011 DAINIK JAGRAN PAGE NO. 11(NEWS PAPER) me news thi k HELTH MINISTRY 2013 se NEET UG implement karegi ap us news ko agar paste karoge to baqi logo ko b ye samajh me aajayega k GOVT. kya chati hai site-WWW.DAINIKJAGRAN.COM

  12. MUNNA BHAI MBBS says:

    world health organisation (WHO) recommende
    doctor/population should 1:600
    but in india as on nov 29 report d/p ratio is 1:2000 very horrible situtation waiting for us

  13. MUNNA BHAI MBBS says:

    “Either we will reject your application or you withdraw your application. Whatever you want to do you can do but we are not going to be party to your decision,” a bench comprising justices H L Dattu and C K Prasad said. “All this order (for the single entrance test) was passed after hearing you (centre). You said draft rules and regulations were in place for implementing it in the academic year 2012-13, ” the bench said. “This court will not be a party (to your decision). We will not be party to all these regulations. Why will we be party to it (for deferring the CEE). Why are you bringing this court in this matter. You better start and withdraw this application,” the bench said.

  14. BABA says:

    to day I contect AIPMT unit on 011-22059683 . my question was about aipmt possibility in 2012 . Unit say that 100 % possibility of aipmt in 2012 . And application form distribution by canra bank next week . cbse sure about aipmt 2012. Application form on printing press . Unit say in hindi .. That aipmt hi hoga neet nahi hoga. So my dear friends don’t waste your time with neet possibilit. Your target on 1 april .

  15. BABA says:

     
    ADMISSION NOTICE FOR MBBS/BDS/BAMS*/B.Pharm.
    COURSES-2012
    The Banaras Hindu University will hold All India COMPE
    TITIVE WRITTEN TEST for admission toMBBS course (8
    4 seats) inTWO stages: PMT-2012 SCREENING and P
    MT-2012 MAIN, and forBDS (38 seats), BAMS* (50 se
    ats) and B. Pharm. (33 seats) courses inONE stage: P
    MT-2012 Screening.
    PMT-2012 SCREENINGshall be held onWednesday, th
    e 16thMay 2012at Varanasi, Delhi, Kolkata, and Hyder
    abad Centres to screen candidates for eligibility to app
    ear inPMT-2012 MAINexamination for MBBS course w
    hich will be held onSunday,the17thJune 2012atVara
    nasi Centre only.For BDS/BAMS*/B.Pharm. courses, c
    andidates will be selected on the basis of their mer
    it in the PMT-2012 SCREENING only.
    *Number of seats in BAMS course may increase subject
    to approval by the Central Council of Indian Medicine.
    ELIGIBILITY :QUALIFICATIONS – Passed Intermediate /
    10+2 or equivalent examination in English, Physics, Ch
    emistry and Biology (Zoology + Botany) taken togethe
    r; (i) For MBBS/BDS/BAMS – a minimum of 50% marks fo
    r General and 45% for General-PC candidates and 40
    % marks for OBC#/SC/ST and respective PC candidates;
    (ii) For B.Pharm. – a minimum of 60% marks for Gener
    al / OBC and respective PC candidates and 55% marks f
    or SC/ST and respective PC candidates. Candidates app
    earing in qualifying examination may also apply.
    DISTRIBUTION OF SEATS:M.B.B.S.(84 seats):General -
    42; OBC#– 23; SC – 13 and ST – 6;BDS(38 seats): Gene
    ral – 19; OBC#– 10; SC – 6 and ST – 3;BAMS(50 seats) :
    General – 25; OBC#– 13; SC – 8 and ST – 4;B.Pharm.(33
    seats): General – 17; OBC#– 9; SC – 5 and ST – 2. Three
    percent seats are reserved for Physically Challenged (P
    C) candidates on horizontal basis in the above courses
    .
    #Non-Creamy layer OBC only.
    AGE:Completed 17 years but not crossed 25 years as
    on 31st December, 2012 (Candidates born after 1st Ja
    nuary, 1996 and on or before 31st December, 1987 n
    eed not apply).
    Sale of Application Form: 09.01.2012 to 05.03.2012
    * from the designated branches of Bank of Baroda
    as mentioned below:
    * Application Form can be obtained fromBank of Baro
    da,BHUBranch, S.S. Hospital, Varanasi upto 12.03.20
    12.
    Application Form can be obtained:
    (a)BY CASH:Rs. 1500/- for GEN/OBC and Rs. 1000/- fo
    r SC/ST candidatesfrom the following branches ofBan
    k of Baroda.
    (1) VARANASI– (i)BHU- S S Hospital Branch,(ii) Ram Kat
    ora Branch, (iii) Orderly Bazar Branch(2) DELHI– (i) Par
    liament Street Branch, (ii) Nehru Place Branch, (iii) Cho
    wk Shakti Nagar Branch(3) KOLKATA– College Street B
    ranch(4) LUCKNOW– Charbagh Branch(5) HYDERABA
    D– Main Branch, ABIDS Circle (6)JAIPUR– DCM Branch(
    7) BHOPAL– TT Nagar Branch  (8) PATNA–  Sri Krishna
    puri(9) BANGALORE– Main Branch, 2, Prithvi Building,
    K.G. Road(10) PUNE– Darekar Heights, 32, Karve Road(
    11) KOTA– Swagat Market, Rampura Bazar(12) BHUB
    ANESWAR– Main Branch (Bapuji Nagar).
    (b)BY POST: From the Office of the Director(PMT-Cell),
    Institute of Medical Sciences, Banaras Hindu University,
    Varanasi-221 005 by sending a written request throu
    ghRegistered Postalong with Crossed Demand Draft/
    Bankers Cheque (MICR only) ofRs. 1600/- for General
    /OBC candidates and Rs. 1100 for SC/ST candidates
    of a Nationalized Bank, drawn in favour of“The Direct
    or, Institute of Medical Sciences,BHU” payable at Va
    ranasi.Application form will be sent by Speed / Registe
    red Post. However, Institute will not be responsible for
    any loss or postal delay. The request for application fo
    rm must include the name and address of the candidat
    e, and full particulars of the enclosed DD/BC (write can
    didate’s name and address on the back of DD). Two sel
    f-addressed, preferably typed, white paper slips of 10
    cm ´ 6 cm size must also accompany it. The requisition
    for PMT Application Form should be superscribed“Req
    uest for Application Form for PMT-2012,BHU”.Last d
    ate of requisition for PMT form by post is 27.02.201
    2.Incomplete/non-cashable Draft (under amount/unsi
    gned/ without Bank Code No. & Seal) shall not be acce
    pted. NOTE: (a)M.O./I.P.O./Chequesshall NOT be acce
    pted under any circumstances.Application Forms fro
    m the Office of the Director (PMT-Cell), Institute of Medi
    cal Sciences,BHU, Varanasi-221005can be obtained b
    y POST only and not in personupto 27.02.2012.
    LAST DATE FOR SUBMISSION OF COMPLETED APPLIC
    ATION FORM:Application form duly completed must b
    e sent throughRegistered Postso as to reach THE DIRE
    CTOR (PMT CELL), INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, BANA
    RAS HINDU UNIVERSITY, VARANASI-221 005 latest by
    15.03.2012. Application forms receivedafter the last
    dateshall not be accepted. Foreign Nationals are not r
    equired to appear in the PMT examination for MBBS/BD
    S/BAMS courses. They may seek admission through the
    Ministry of External Affairs, Govt. of India, New Delhi, a
    s per the rules laid down for the purpose and their no
    mination must reach by 15.07.2012. 

  16. rajput says:

    hey all
    common guys we all know this is india …… neet this fast is not possible in india. even sc had said that if u have other means to postpone exams then do it. something or other will come out.

    just keep preparing for state pmt….

    waise kisi ne chikni chameli ko dekha kya .. hottttttttttt

  17. kumar says:

    HYDERABAD: Minister for Health DL Ravindra Reddy left for New Delhi on Saturday to clear the uncertainty over the implementation of National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) for admission into medical colleges in the state. He is scheduled to meet Union Minister for Health Gulam Nabi Azad on Sunday.

    Supreme court ke dande ka asar
    http://ibnlive.in.com/news/dl-in-delhi-to-clarify-on-neet/212921-60-121.html
    Ravindra Reddy has gone to ascertain whether students from Andhra Pradesh would be exempted from NEET for the academic year 201213 in the wake of the Supreme Court stressing on the implementation of NEET examination from next year.

    Ravindra Reddy said that the government is pressing for exemption keeping in mind the level of preparedness of the students.

  18. Rockstar says:

    @Srikanth
    only manipal and bhu have released notification for mbbs admission, when other institutes are releasing there notification

    • mohd javed kanpur says:

      Filed under ADMISSION NEWS by NBM on DECEMBER 18, 2011 AT 3:18 AM

      MGIMS MBBS admissions 2012
      Filed under ADMISSION NEWS by NBM on DECEMBER 18, 2011 AT 3:18 AM{NO COMMENTS}
      KHS Mahatma Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences MBBS admissions 2012

      Mahatma Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences (MGIMS), Kasturba Health Society, invites applications for admission to MBBS course starting from 1st July 2012.

      Eligibility:

      Age: 17 years as on or before 31st December 2011

      Must have passed 10 + 2 system of Maharashtra State Higher Secondary Education Board or equivalent examination of any recognised Board or any Indian University with English, Physics, Chemistry and Biology with minimum 50% marks taken together in Physics,Chemistry and Biology.

      Selection will be based on Entrance Examination to be held on 15th April 2012 at Nagpur, Delhi, Hyderabad Mumbai, Varanasi & Kolkata.

      For application and other details visit MGIMS website

      Application deadline: 29-02-2012

  19. Rockstar says:

    Dude i dont know whats happening in our country
    they should give the final decision as fast as possible

  20. Student says:

    Hi all Guys, AIPMT 2012 is going to happen and notification will come in couple of days. CBSE said that the aipmt 2012 is going to happen surely and not neet. To see log on to http://www.cbse.nic.in and see the news

  21. RISE OF JATT says:

    NEET IN 2013 IS IN NO WAY A CONTEMPT OF COURT. SUPREME COURT WANTS TO KEEP THEMSELVES AWAY FROM THIS MATTER . ALL THEY HAVE SAID IS THAT THEY DON’T WANT TO BE A PART OF THIS DECISION.

    still people here are thinking of neet . guys better stop till 2013. had sc been involved in this matter that seriously then they would have strictly ordered to conduct the exam and u would have heard the final verdict till now. when mci and govt. itself don’t think 2012neet is possible then why are u all keeping such dreams ………….

  22. Game Over says:

    Madarchodon behen ke lodon jaldi se koi faisla lo warna teri maa chod denge.

  23. purna says:

    purna :
    Start NEET in 2012, but in regional language also at least in 2012.

  24. raj roshan says:

    am from bihar …… i want to know weather neet has been cancelled or not ?????
    neet in 2012 is a burden . they had declared aipmt but now this news is coming . someone confirm the news plz.

    • Udit Upadhyay says:

      it is quiet obvious from cbse’s press release that if supreme court allows then only they will postpone neet for 2013, but SC wants it in 2012. And my dear freind is desh mein SC se upar koi nahi hai even parliament

  25. HAI HAI says:

    The condition of present Govt. is like a prostitute. The White criminals want to anything at the cost of money. SC has fired these criminals but who cares. Halat yeh hai ki sali izzat nilam ho rahi to kya, pvt medical colleges se paise to aa rahe hain. I received SMS through which i came to know the rates in pvt medical colleges .Rates are higher by almost 4-5 lacs higher as compared to last year. The market news is that officials have been paid very high amount for cancellation of NEET. NEET is at the mercy of only APEX court. Let us see what’s happen.

  26. kumar says:

    contempt of court is very difficult to goverment ,now they will think 100 times to cancel neet. as this govt were saving A.Raja ,Kalmadi and hasan ali it is the supreme court who put them behind bar.

    lets see what happen in next week any way cbse has written in teir press note”As per communication received from Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India regarding seeking permission from the Hon’ble Supreme Court to allow introduction of NEET for Under Graduate Medical Courses from the academic year 2013-14 instead of 2012-13″

    so permission not granted it is simple that now CBSE have to arrange neet as it has said many times that cbse is ready for neet and same thing said in court.

  27. MUNNA BHAI MBBS says:

    GAME RELODED,
    m just thinking over decismade by health ministry and the responsible minister how and why they annauonced for aipmt 2012 is neet final decis was pending in suprem court.. what they think? nonsance ministry and stupid ministers…what a combination in india.. incredible india… realy great

  28. varun chawala says:

    what the hell is happening . just when the studies went to normal they have planned to ruin again. when no one is wanting neet then why is sc so particular about it.
    jab padhai mein focus lagne laga tabhi kide kar diye.

  29. Sandeep Chaudhary says:

    S a a a l o…….h r a m k h o r o…..Ek kaam to sahi se karo baniya ki dukan bana rakhi hai mol bhaw ker rahae ho…..ham neet ki taiyari kare ki state pmt……….last me kahin ye decision mat le lena ki iss saal koi medical ka exam hi nahi hoga………! koi bharosa nahi isss indian system ka…..!!!

  30. mci agent says:

    kya ho raha hai yaar dimaag ka dahi kar diya hai, mai to kehta hu neet ko june me le jao aur sabhi states ka jo common syllabus hai usi ke according exam lo aur mci ko try karna chahiye ki regional language me bhi paper set kare……. what say guys!!!!!!

  31. mci agent says:

    NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Friday embarrassed the Union government and Medical Council of India (MCI) by forcing them to withdraw their pleas for one-year deferment of the first-ever National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) 2012, a single examination for MBBS and dental undergraduate seats in all medical colleges in the country.

    While MCI’s counsel, senior advocate Amarendra Saran, was quick to sense the mood of the court to immediately agree for an unconditional withdrawal of the regulatory body’s application, additional solicitor general Harin Raval, while agreeing to withdraw the plea by the ministry of health and family welfare, wanted recording of his statement that the government would take appropriate steps in this regard.

    This made a bench of Justices H L Dattu and C K Prasad recall that the common entrance test was formulated on the joint request of the MCI and the health ministry.

    “All these orders were passed after hearing you and you alone. The regulations have been framed by the MCI stipulating that NEET would be held from the academic year 2012-13 onwards. We will not be a party to the postponement of these regulations. If the government and the regulator want to withdraw the regulations, let them do that,” the bench said.

    Raval persisted with his request, “I want to withdraw the application but please record my statement that the government will take appropriate steps.”

    The bench shot back, “We will not record a word of it. Either you withdraw the application or we reject it. If you have other methods open to you for postponement of NEET, you are free to do that.” It went on to order dismissal of the ministry’s application but on Raval’s request, changed the order and recorded the permission to withdraw it.

    The Union government had moved the application for deferment of NEET 2012 by one year following objections by West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee and other states. The test is scheduled to be held on May 13, 2012.

    One of the major reasons for the Centre moving the application was the Trinamool government’s insistence on West Bengal students being given the option of answering the test in Bengali language and some other states either seeking exemption or deferment.

    It had said, “The chief minister of West Bengal has expressed preference to continue with the Joint Entrance Examination Board for all colleges in West Bengal. However, the state would be ready to join NEET for undergraduate courses only if it is assured that Bengali language would be one of the medium for the said examination.”

    The chief ministers of Maharashtra, Assam, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka requested the health minister for exemption from NEET 2012 on the ground that students would require some more time to switch over to the new system and get fully acquainted with the syllabus prescribed by MCI. Maharashtra, Gujarat and Goa showed readiness to join NEET from 2013-14 but AP sought exemption for two years, saying it would join from 2014-15, the health ministry had said.

    Given the myriad reasons for states not preferring NEET 2012, the health ministry said, “The government of India is of the strong view that instead of hurriedly implementing NEET from academic year 2012, it would be in the fitness of things if the same is introduced in a more planned manner from the academic year 2013-14 onwards.

  32. venkat(vijayawada) says:

    still my comments are being removed .

    • b k gupta says:

      KARNATKA, MAHARSHTRA AUR AP TO PATLI GALI SE NIKAL GAYE LEKIN BECHARI MAMTA KO FANSA DIYA .GOVT.KO LETTER TO KIRAN KUMAR, CHAUHAN AUR GOWDA SAHEB NE BHI BHEJA THA LEKIN UNKE LETTER KI TO CHARCHA HI NAHIN HUI. BECHARI MAMTA KE LEETER KA JIKRA KAR DIYA. PATA HI NAHI UNKO KI AISE LETTER BHIJWANE KE PAHLE KETNE MAFIYON KA HAATH HAI.

  33. sahil ahuja says:

    guys relax ……. even last year they had played such games and such games went on till march ……. don’t worry neet won’t be possible.
    the point to notice is that sc wants neet pg also to be conducted next year . ha ha ha
    mci and health ministry has showed their dissatisfaction for neet ……….

    • rajeev raj says:

      last year suprem court acepetd tha perposal to ho hol neet from 2012. but this time apex court reffused to acept perposal to deffer neet from 2012…so th little difference this time

  34. venkat(vijayawada) says:

    wtf for a moment i thought the problem has been solved ……… shame on sc ……… india should be changed into a communist ….. china way better than india ………….
    am pre paring for my final exams now they still discussing about neet …….neet in 2012 is not possible …….. somebody open the eyes of the idiots ……….

  35. Abhishek Raj says:

    What is happening in our education system.Who is responsible for this .Every concerned particularly Ed.Minister .They have not tken the matter seriously , that is why now students suffering a lot . Now what is expecting about NEET 2012.

  36. VIJAY M KIRI says:

    I think Supreme Court should have been told to visualize a situation where in they were told to study a different syllabus just before appearing for final LL.B.exam ,how they would have reacted????

    It is just ridiculous that no body wants to get in to the shoes of the state board students who are in nook and corner of the country and all are indulging in to the blame game.The students are in the final leg of their preparation of HSC board exam.in Feb./Mar.2012 followed by State CET..Creating such uncertainties at this juncture will only spoil their careers for no fault of theirs.

    • B K GUPTA says:

      @Kiri
      Do not repeat your stupid arguments. You are an agent of Pvt medical colleges which U are hiding since long.U are just taking the state board plea. Why are U spoiling the future of bright students for the sake of your selfishness. Money is not everything , mind it.

      • VIJAY M KIRI says:

        @BKG,

        According to you only CBSE students are bright as it is they whose day dreaming of grabbing seats from state board students,is going to take beating.I am not ashamed of taking state board plea as i belong to one and a hard working student.Not like you who want to grab seats by reducing competition.Incidentally,sometime back i had suggested you to start educating rural students about NEET as most of them do not even know about it.What is the progress on that????.

        You better mind your language and find some other avenue for venting out frustration.

  37. sanjay says:

    NEET_2012 is sure otherwise it will be contempt of Hon,S Court order given in March,2010.

  38. preethi says:

    it is the problem with our education system and politics.. when brainless people r sitting in policy making seats they behave like as usual like ..MAD TUGLAK… till the the time RIGHT PEOPLE are not taking charge of it.. INDIAN STUDENTS WILL SUFFER LIKE THIS.. GOD SAVES THIS COUNTRY AND STUDENTS..

  39. Dr Praveen says:

    it is the problem with our education system and politics.. when brainless people r sitting in policy making seats they behave like as usual like ..MAD TUGLAK… till the the time RIGHT PEOPLE are not taking charge of it.. INDIAN STUDENTS WILL SUFFER LIKE THIS.. GOD SAVES THIS COUNTRY AND STUDENTS..

  40. sam says:

    कृपया ख़बर को ध्यान से पढ़ कर समझे ,
    सर्वोच न्यायालय ने कहा हे कि
    सरकार व mci चाहे जो फैसला कर सकती हैं ,
    और सरकार के फैसले से सर्वोच न्यायालय को कोई एतराज नहीं होगा .
    So you can understand that desire of government

  41. sameer dudhe says:

    hell am ashamed to be an indian now.
    isn’t sc the most powerful institution in india.
    hell if sc will play with our lives then who should we look forward to . when the governmeant is not at all interested in conducting the exam then why force it .
    sala phir dimag padhai se ghum gaya hai .

  42. KHYATI GOHIL says:

    yep the decision os in mci’s hand but the government f india itself dosent want to conduct neet this year!!! so why the hell will neet be iplemented this year???anyways isnt it too late to release an official notification that too with the aipmt datws out!!!
    i guess we will have clear idea only when some application forms start coming out!! hell with our legislative and judiciary system…

  43. kumar says:

    @jo english nahi samjhate hai unke liye hindi me news

    एमबीबीएस कामन एंट्रेंस टेस्ट पर केंद्र को लगी फटकार

    नई दिल्ली/अमर उजाला ब्यूरो।

    Story Update : Saturday, December 17, 2011 2:59 AM

    केंद्र सरकार को शुक्रवार को उस समय सुप्रीम कोर्ट की नाराजगी का सामना करना पड़ा, जब सरकार की ओर से मेडिकल कोर्स एमबीबीएस-एमडी के लिए देशभर में एक साथ आयोजित की जानी वाली पहली समान्य राष्ट्रीय योग्यता प्रवेश परीक्षा को आगे बढ़ाने की मांग पर शीर्षस्थ अदालत ने असहमति जता दी। सर्वोच्च अदालत ने कहा कि सरकार इस मामले में कोई फर्क नहीं पड़ता और हम इस मामले में किसी तरह का हस्तक्षेप नहीं करने जा रहे हैं। इसलिए सरकार इस मामले में ऐसी मांग करने पर कोई निर्णय नहीं ले सकती कि समान्य प्रवेश परीक्षा को एक साल आगे 2013 तक बढ़ा दिया जाए।

    शैक्षणिक सत्र में लागू करने के लिए पेश
    जस्टिस एचएल दत्तू व जस्टिस सीके प्रसाद की पीठ ने कहा कि सरकार अपने आवेदन को वापस लेगी या फिर अदालत आवेदन को खारिज कर दे। आप जो भी चाहते हैं करिए, क्योंकि हम इस मामले में हस्तक्षेप नहीं करने जा रहे हैं। इस मामले में जो भी आदेश जारी किए गए थे वह आपके सलाह के बाद जारी किए गए थे। सरकार ने नियम और कानून से संबंधित मसौदा सामान्य प्रवेश परीक्षा को 2012-13 के शैक्षणिक सत्र में लागू करने के लिए पेश किया था। आप इस मामले में अदालत क्यों आए हैं। बेहतर यही होगा कि आप इस आवेदन को वापस ले लें।

    इस परीक्षा को आयोजित कराने से इनकार
    केंद्रीय स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय की ओर से शीर्षस्थ अदालत में आवेदन कर प्रवेश परीक्षा को एक साल आगे बढ़ाने की मांग की गई है, क्योंकि कई राज्य सरकारों ने छात्रों के पाठ्यक्रम में अचानक बदलाव को लेकर इस परीक्षा को आयोजित कराने से इनकार कर दिया है, जबकि कुछ की ओर से शर्तें रख दी गई हैं। पश्चिम बंगाल सरकार ने कहा है कि वह इस परीक्षा को राज्य में तभी आयोजित करेगी, जब यह बांग्ला भाषा में भी कराई जाएगी। याद रहे कि सर्वोच्च अदालत ने इसी साल मार्च में केंद्र और भारतीय चिकित्सा महासंघ (एमसीआई) को यह परीक्षा आयोजित कराने की अनुमति प्रदान की थी, लेकिन केंद्र सरकार को राज्य सरकारों के अड़ियल रवैये के चलते सुप्रीम कोर्ट में आवेदन दाखिल करने पर मजबूर होना पड़ा। वहीं, एमसीआई की ओर से भी एक आवेदन सीईई और पोस्ट ग्रेजूएट कोर्स के मामले में भी दायर किया गया है। हालांकि अदालत की ओर से असहमति जताए जाने पर केंद्र और एमसीआई दोनों ने अपने आवेदन वापस ले लिया।

  44. GAZALA says:

    is it a joke going on…….???????????????
    I m not getting that our honorable supreme court,MCI,CBSE etc are actually planing to prove what
    ??////its really very very disturbing.please don’t keep on shuttling the decision.plz let us study with a clear mindset………

  45. Subhankar says:

    Let’s see how MCI handles this,

  46. vatsana says:

    phir se nahi .
    sc court ko kya problem ho gayi. bloody idiots playing with our lives . no neet plzzzzzzzzzz……….

  47. Rockstas says:

    Hi Srikanth is it possible that now they can give a notification of Neet-ug 2012 postponing aipmt 2012

  48. Game Over says:

    SC raps govt, MCI on deferring medical entrance test NEET Dec 17, 2011, 02.46AM IST TNN [ Dhananjay Mahapatra ]
    NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court onFriday embarrassed the Union government and Medical Council of India (MCI) by forcing them to withdraw their pleas for one-yeardeferment of the first-ever National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) 2012, a single examination for MBBS and dental undergraduate seats in all medical colleges in the country.
    While MCI’s counsel, senior advocate Amarendra Saran, was quick to sense the mood of the court to immediately agree for anunconditional withdrawal of the regulatory body’s application, additional solicitor general Harin Raval, while agreeing to withdraw the plea by the ministryof health and family welfare, wanted recording of his statement that the government would take appropriate steps in this regard

    • D B Sarkar says:

      Now only one middle path is available with the Central Govt……pan-India NEET 2012 for 15 % govt quota (as a clone of AIPMT 2012) and extended NEET 2012 for 85% seats of WILLING states.
      Central govt can not afford to go against its regional allies like TMC ,DMK, etc ….

  49. Game Over says:

    Home | More Sections | Scorecard | Most Read | Videos | mPaper | Apps
    SC raps govt, MCI on deferring medical entrance test NEET Dec 17, 2011, 02.46AM IST TNN [ Dhananjay Mahapatra ]
    NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court onFriday embarrassed the Union government and Medical Council of India (MCI) by forcing them to

  50. Game Over says:

    Though I welcome neet but unfortunately in a country of jugad neet never possible.

  51. yadav says:

    In the interest of the majority of non CBSE students of all the States , the Union Government, MCI and CBSE should of think of refraining from introduction of any new system for the timebeing. They should not bring SC in the picture now.SC has permitted to conduct NEET if the Govt is ready to do so with all proper preparations in place , regulations are framed and all stake holders are agreeing to them without any ambiguity to conduct a Nation wide test.Now we are just in the beginning of framing the regulations in the fag end of the academic year.Supreme court and Union Govt should ensure that the students especially from poor family and villages are not effected by any change. regarding Medical admission statusco has to be maintained now. every effort has to be made by all concerned to iron out the differeneces in the sylabus, difference of opinion among the states , regional language issue etc etc. with in a couple of years and intoduce NEET properly without any ambiguity as per the permission given by the SC. People should refrain from confusing the students . AIPMT is already declared by CBSE and some state PMTs are also declared. Bright Students especially from the state boards are now busy in preparations of the board exam and the PMTs.Kindly do not trouble them.

  52. purna says:

    Start NEET in 2012, but in regional language also at least in 2012.

  53. purna says:

    Start NEET in 2012 and but in regional language also at least in 2012.

  54. AMITABH from KBC says:

    suno dosto SC ne kaha hai k govt. jo karna chahti hai kar sakti hai par SC usme koi interefere ni karega lekin ab sahi bat ye hai k ab faisla MCI k pale me hai

  55. Rahul says:

    Can cbse start selling their application forms for AIPMT and hold AIPMT Exam without taking SC’s permission to do so?!!I think NO…and that’s why they have not even upgraded their official website which is still showing for AIPMT 2011!!! what’s going on!!everywhere is politics…Sick of these guilty game of politics that even not leave the Students like US….Shitttt…go 2 HELLLLLL…

  56. RISE OF JATT says:

    guys if u read the above written article properly u all will understand what little chance neet has …… sc has said “do whatever u want to “……..

    any way , bahut time se is site pe kuch likha nahi ja raha tha , ab nautanki phir shuru ho gayi …….
    intelligent students study for aipmt ……..

  57. RISE OF JATT says:

    ha ha ah
    same thing that happened last year . but guys not to worry we know how it would end .
    i don’t get one thing that when states had approached sc for exemption then why did the sc not reacted properly.
    sc is a stupid institution …….

  58. anushka says:

    jaise taise padhai par concentrate karna shuru kiya tha par fir naya drama shuru….

  59. Udit Upadhyay says:

    IT’S ALL DEAR FREIND, MCI HAS GOT IT VERY INTELLIGENTLY. THEY DESERVE A VERY VERY HUGE APPLAUSE!!!, NOW HARDWORL WILL GET ITS REWARD

  60. Udit Upadhyay says:

    CLEVER MCI PLAYED IT WELL, THE BALL IS ON THEIR SIDE NOW. SO DEAR STUDENTS GET READY 4 THE NEET-UG 2012 NOTIFICATION VERY VERY SOON….

  61. priya says:

    wtf these people are dOin !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    when thEse dUmbs r gOin tO giVe fiNal DecisiON ?????????

  62. robin says:

    i guess & i believe ki neet 2013 may ho raha hai..
    Few ppl r preparing 4 getting addmission in 2013 whn neet will take place …chalo koie nahi
    It’s going 2 aipmt in 2012…

  63. Udit Upadhyay says:

    JAY HO!!! NEET 2012

  64. Prince says:

    The first ever single window national entrance test
    for MBBS and postgraduate admissions in the
    country looks all set to be a reality next year after
    the Centre’s attempt to defer it by a year got shot
    down by Supreme Court on Friday.
    .
    .
    .
    The Court found no reason to entertain requests put
    forth by Union Health Ministry and Medical Council of
    India (MCI) to defer the National Eligibility-cum-
    Entrance Test (NEET) for under-graduate and
    postgraduate courses (also common entrance test (CET
    for MBBS courses) to 2012-13 citing practical problems. Both the Centre and MCI were heard before the Court
    had passed an order giving the green signal for NEET. Seeing the Centre’s flip-flop, the bench of Justices HL
    Dattu and CK Prasad refused to be dragged into the
    controversy. It said, “We will not be a party to
    postponement of these regulations…You better start
    preparations to implement it from 2012-13. We will
    not allow you to postpone.” The Ministry’s application read as follows: “The
    conduct of Under Graduate National Eligibility-cum-
    Entrance Test (UG-NEET) is a Herculean task which
    requires great deal of preparation and for paucity of
    time it is practically impossible to resolve the issues
    raised by various State Governments and hold the UG- NEET in 2012.” The application cited the various objections raised by
    States, for instance, Maharashtra, Gujarat and Goa
    willing to join the national test from 2013-14, Andhra
    Pradesh seeking an exemption of two years, Kerala
    demanding its reservation policies to be kept intact,
    Assam disputing with criteria for minimum marks, West Bengal for inclusion of Bengali language as a
    medium for conduct of the said examination and
    Puducherry wanting exemption from the NEET. The bench dismissed the Centre’s demand and allowed
    MCI to withdraw its application. However, the option
    of rescinding the guidelines for NEET is still open as the
    Government could still by issuing a notification
    withdraw its decision to hold a common test to enable
    lakhs of medical aspirants to apply for medical seats across the country through a single window test
    instead of appearing for 26 exams. Through the NEET,
    admissions to 15 per cent all India quota and 85 per
    cent state quota seats in MBBS courses. Earlier, the difference of views within the Government
    on this issue was evident in the SC last week when
    opposed to Health Ministry application, the Central
    Bureau of Secondary Education (CBSE) filed an
    application seeking permission to conduct the test
    from next academic year.

    • b k gupta says:

      DEAR PRINCE,

      You may not like it but one thing is sure NET will never happen in india because it will hamper the business of more than 1000 cr. of rupees. This will hamper the interest of broker / education mafia, white criminals etc. Money is everything for such people. Therefore, untill and unless corrupt ministers, its official exist , NEET will never happen. These people enjoy the moments while selling the coffin and abroo of their mother.

  65. Udit Upadhyay says:

    YAAR AB JAAKE SACHAI KI JEET HUI HAI, MERI TOH IS DESH SE UMMIDEIN KHATAM HI HO GAYEE THI, LONG LIVE SC, HEARTIEST THANKS TO MCI, THEY FOUGHT TREMENDOUSLY. HATS OFF!!!

    • Prince says:

      @udit….
      Totally agree with u frnd…
      Now its upto mci and cbse..
      Lets see what they are going to do now… Hope for the best…

  66. Prince says:

    hey srikanth…
    In the very first line u have writen ”medical council of india has filed an affidavit in supreme court”
    But i think it was ministry of health and family welfare to file the affidavit..
    Plz dude check this and rectify if i m correct…!!!!

  67. madhusudhan chowdhary says:

    don’t start it again ………..

  68. Prince says:

    yaaaahhoooooooo…!!!!!!!!
    God tussi great ho..
    Sc tussi v bade great ho…!!!!

  69. robin says:

    @srikanth sir kyaa neet 2012 may ho saktha hai
    Aap k according in present situation plss reply
    Sir…

  70. robin says:

    hey bhagwan neet mat hone dena plsss in 2012…aap koie twist naa aaye…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


seven × 3 =

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Social comments

comments