MCI Notification on NEET UG Stayed in Karnataka

Earlier we had reported that Karnataka too is opting out of NEET UG 2012 the proposed common medical entrance test by the medical education regulatory body MCI. As a breather to many private medical colleges in the state of Karnataka; the high court stayed the notification issued by MCI. (via)

The petition in the high court was filed by the Karnataka Private Medical and Dental Colleges association challenging the MCI’s move of trashing the state level medical entrance test. Over the years each medical college has adopted their own selection process, state based colleges are now refusing the sudden change MCI wants to bring in.

Although MCI was desperate of holding NEET UG on May 13, 2012, each state is chasing away the dream of MCI. This might just cause more panic to the students who have started preparing according to the newly proposed syllabus by MCI for the maiden National Eligibility cum Entrance Test for undergraduate admissions.

MCI wanted to have full control on medical colleges in India and hence has proposed a common medical entrance test; the objective was to keep medical education clean and transparent. But it is too late for MCI to do this year.

Students are mislead with a new announcement every next day, nothing has been materialized  for them. If you are a student we want to ask you? How do you react to the latest development related to the entrance exam drama? Do share with us.

You are reading this article on blog.careermitra.com, stay tuned for career & education news!

Social comments

comments

Posted in Medical and tagged , .

71 Comments

    • abe gawariyat ke badshah , ek baat to paki hai ki tojhe neet ke bare kuch nahin pata ( tere comments niche ke batate hain ) …….. sale chaprasi ki naukri dhund le aur is site se nikal ja ……. agar sharafat se baat karna nahin ati to bhag ja yahan se , gamer ko kuch mat bol . woh tujhse kahin jyada samajdar maloom padta hai ………..

  1. dude u r srsly dying of insecurity…
    neways jitna blog karna ho kar le neet to ho kar hi rahega…khaas kar tere gaon haryana me…
    chal good nyt

    • pehli baat main hp se hoon aur dusri main abhishek ki batoon se sehmat hoon …… tujhse lad kar mujhe kuch nahi milega …….. and i an insecure and am damn sure that all people on this blog are …….. why the f**k has mci not made any announcement………

  2. MR IDIOT
    DO YOU KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT MEDICAL EXAMS………..
    THESE 15 % SEATS ARE THE SAME WHICH ALL INDIA PMT PROVIDES ……. IF STATE STUDENTS WISH TO GIVE THEN THEY CAN GIVE AIPMT ……
    THESE 15% SEATS ARE AROUND 3500 IN NO. ……
    DUDE BEFORE PREPARING FOR EXAMS FIND ABOUT THESE EXAMS THEN TALK …… YOU HAVE WASTED ENOUGH OF MY TIME ……..

  3. GAMER BHAI AND SAR BHAI
    adhi raat ko lad rahe ho yaar ……. isse acha padh lo ……. mushkil hi hai ki neet hoga ……….. hum sabki problem ka jad mci hai …… use gali deni hai to do ……. hum sabka ek hi aim hai phir kyun apas mein ladna
    @sar bhai november khatam hone ko aya hai ab kahan neet ho sakta hai………

  4. retard u r…

    the states r afraid dat there seats wil b taken away by other state ka students…
    so a**crack…if d cbse student get admssn then it wil b frm d state only…dat was my point…
    n i xpected sumthng better dan d emotional quotient u juz said…

    • YOU YOURSELF IS PROVING HOW BIG DUMB YOU ARE

      STATES ARE OPPOSING BECAUSE THEY STATE STUDENTS ARE NOT BEING EQUAL CHANCE ….. THAT IS WHY THEY WANT IT IN 2013….. THAT IS IT …….
      I DON’T UNDERSTAND Y U CANNOT EVEN GIVE THEM 1 YEAR CHANCE…..
      DUDE U SERIOUSLY NEED TO GO TO BASICS OF NEET AND KNOW WHY IT IS BEING OPPOSED ……..

      YOU GIVE ME SOME STRONG REASON FOR NEET ……… PLZ NO CORRUPTION AGAIN ……

      • SRIKANT SIR WHY HAS MY REPLY TO SAR BEEN REMOVED ……. HE USED FOUL LANGUAGE FOR ME THAT IS WHY I USED FOR HI M …… PLZ SHOE\W THE COMMENT ………

  5. ATTENTION ATTENTION ATTENTION
    DISCLAIMER
    after research it has been found that there is a noob in this blog named ‘game changer’…yeah u heard it ryt it d gamechanger( the name has been inherited by a probable child who has juz started playin cs)…no dis is not d disclaimer,it has been found dat dis guy is bloging repeatedly fo months n barking abt pro n anti neet points…so d obvious conclusion to dis worthless research is dat dis guy himself is not studyn n continiously blabbering abt neet..if he was dis concernd then he shud hav STFU n studied till dis tym…
    so in short every1 is noticed to not indulge in interaction wid dis attention seekin psycho!!!
    rest its up to u…
    good luck :)

  6. hmmm….
    the” game changer”!!
    u askin me abt d details of d benifits itself is more than enuf to justify ur lack of knowledge…
    i hav found out dat u r present in most of the blogs in recent tym related to d same issue…so i recon u r either dumb to not hav notice the benifits or u r actin ignorant juz to prove ur point…
    in any case let me tel u dat the probability of neet was notified in d begining of the academic session…
    further the syllabus was declared xactly 6 monyhs b4….n accordin to our constitution ne change in entrance pattern shud b notifyd atleast six months b4…so legally the mci is ryt….

    so stop being cry baby abt u goin thru injustice….

    this neet will only promote meritorious students…
    n those states where the syllabus is d issue shud even stop worrying coz along wid the air there wil b state merit rank…which requires u to have domicile of the state…
    instead of cursing neet u shud b thankfull to mci coz now u can contest for atleast 15% of the seats of the whole nation…which is more than wat ur state offer quantitatively…
    wel datz abt d benefits of it …
    n abt d corruption part then recommend u to go thru dinesh kumar’s comment…

    no offence to ur beliefs but do preach ir thoughts after havin genuine n rational reasons supportin them…
    in ur case if u hav then do let me n every1 else knw…

    wil b waiyin fo ur reply,
    yours
    sar

    • WELL WAS WAITING FOR YOUR REPLY
      MR IDIOT
      YOU ARE CALLING ME A DUMB BUT MR IDIOT WHAT U HAVE WRITTEN IS ACTUALLY MAKING ME LAUGH ( I LITERALLY MEAN IT ) . YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT NEET IS AND WHY U ARE SUPPORTING IT……… LET ME CLEAR U FEW THINGS

      1) this neet will only promote meritorious students…
      instead of cursing neet u shud b thankfull to mci coz now u can contest for atleast 15% of the seats of the whole nation…which is more than wat ur state offer quantitatively…
      wel datz abt d benefits of it …

      THIS ITSELF SHOWS YOUR IGNORANCE.
      NEET IS IN NO WAY ENCOURAGING MERITIOUS STUDENTS…… 85% RESERVATION REMAINS AND ONLY 15% OUTSIDE STUDENTS ARE ALLOWED …. THIS WAS THE CASE IN STATE PMT AND AIPMT … NOTHING IS CHANGING HERE EXCEPT THAT THE EXTRA CHANCE THAT STATE PMT PROVIDES U IS BEING TAKEN AWAY ……… NEET IS ONLY COMBINING BOTH WITHOUT CHANGING NEET ……SO NO MERITIOUS STUDENT WILL BE AT ADVANTAGE WITH NEET ……….

      2)n those states where the syllabus is d issue shud even stop worrying coz along wid the air there wil b state merit rank…which requires u to have domicile of the state…
      DUDE MBBS EXAM HAS LOT OF EMOTIONS ATTACHED TO IT………. ANY SMALL CHANGE CAN PRESSURIZE THE STUDENT……… PLUS STATE RANK WILL ALSO BE ACHIEVED BY THE CBSE STUDENTS WHO HOLD AN EDGE ON STATE STUDENTS …….

      3) AS FOR CORRUIPTION ALL RIGHTS OF ASMITTING THE STUDENT IS BEING KEPT BY THE STATE SO CORRUPTION WILL STILL BE PREVELING AND FURTHER HOW CAN YOU TRUST THOSE WHO ARE CONDUCTING NEET ….
      DINESH AND 2- 3 OTHER SUPPORTERS HAVE ALWAYS PASTED THE OLD NEWS OF CORRUPTION – I MEAN WHAT HAS TAKEN PLACE …… THEY ARE NOT SAYING THAT NEET IS SOLVING CORRUPTION ….. I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR FROM U ON THIS ISSUE AS HOW NEET IS STOPPING CORRUPTION………..

      I HOPE THIS WIIL DO SOME GOOD IN OPENING YOUR EYES …… I HAVE BEEN OPPOSING NEET FOR A LONG TIME NOW AND HAVE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATIONS ALL GOOD AND BAD THINGS OF NEET ………

      AND WHICH OTHER PLACE HAVE U SEEN ME……….

  7. Gamer yeh tum bol rahe ho ? Surprising ! Because you and sam are only the lone neet supporters here using dozens of other names to post. Jab neet ke against support kam pad gaya to jaali tarike se ghost figure la rahe. Aur yahi kam neet supporters bhi kar rahe hain. Mujhe pata hai yahan par anti aur pro neet ke liye sirf 5-6 log hi hain jo pichle 3 mahine se apas mein lad rahe hai. Thik hai tum neet nahi chahte ho par tumhara state haryana ne abhi tak awaz kyun nahin uthai. Northern states mein sab neet ke liye razi hain kyunki unko isme koi problem nahi. Southern states hi sirf oppose kar rahe hain jiska reason dinesh ne niche post kiya hua hai. 75 % chances hain Neet ho kar hi rahega chahe 4-5 states ko chod hi diya jaye. Instead of fighting everyone pls go back to studies. Dec start hone wala hai agar ab bhi tum sab nahi sudhre to bad mein kitne bhi asun baha lo yeh waqt laut ke nahi ayega. Jinko med nikalna hai acche collg se din mein abhi 10-12 ghante padh rahe hain.

    • HELLO DINESH KUMAR
      KOI FARAK NAHI PADTA TUM KYA SOCHTE HO ………… TUM SABNE APNI AAKHON PE PATI BANDH RAKI HAI ISLIYE SABKO LAGTA HAI KI MAIN GHOST FIGURE BANAKE LIKHTA HOON …… PAR TUMKO JO SOCHNA WOH SOCHO …… SACHAI KA MUJHE PATA HAI ….. SAM NE TO LIKHNA TAK CHOD DIYA HAI….. ITNI TO AKAL LAGAO KYA ITNE SARE OPPOSERS KEVAL DO LOG HO SAKTE HAIN ……….

    • Hi Shiekh, Your comment is not shown in our back end as well, it is possible when you submitted the connection might have lost between you and our server. Please repost.

  8. I don’t get why are people shouting here about neet …. face it neet is not possible in 2012 ….. mci should play safe and announce it in 2014.

  9. HELLO SRIKANTH WHY SOME OF MY COMMENTS HAVE BEEN REMOVED …….. I DID NOT USE ANY BAD LANGUAGE BUT STILL YOU REMOVED THEM

    • Exempt Maharashtra From
      NEET 2012: Chavan PTI | MUMBAI | NOV 22, 2011 PRINT COMMENTS Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan has
      urged the Centre to exempt the state from the
      National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) (under
      graduate) for the year 2012 owing to the
      difference between the CBSE syllabus and that of
      the state board. The NEET will be held in May next year for the
      under-graduate and post-graduate medical
      admission. As per a new Government of India (GoI)
      regulation, there will be a common NEET for the
      medical students from all over the country. In a letter to the Union Health Minister Ghulam Nabi
      Azad, Chavan said the syllabus recently declared for
      NEET 2012 by the CBSE is different from the syllabus
      of the Maharashtra board. He felt it was too late to inform the new syllabus to
      the students concerned and ask them to prepare
      for the test. Chavan told the union minister that medical
      admissions in the state are carried out on the basis
      of state-level common entrance test, which is
      conducted in Marathi, English and Urdu. NEET 2012 will be conducted in English and Hindi
      only. This will cause injustice to the students
      appearing for the 12th standard examinations in
      Urdu and Marathi from Maharashtra, the chief
      minister said. Chavan further said as per the approval of the
      Supreme Court, the Centre is directing the Medical
      Council of India (MCI) to conduct the NEET (UG) and
      NEET (PG). As per the information from the MCI,
      NEET (UG) is to be conducted in 2012 and NEET (PG)
      from 2013. “So there is a disparity in implementation of these
      two examinations. The judgement does not
      mention the date of implementation. It appears that
      Government of India is deciding the date of
      implementations. Instead of conducting the NEET
      (UG) in 2012 and NEET (PG) in 2013, both examinations should be conducted from 2013,” he
      said. Chavan said the present syllabus of NEET
      (undergraduate) is closer to CBSE syllabus and far
      different from the state board syllabus. “This will favour 15 to 20 per cent students of CBSE
      from the state and cause injustice to approximately
      80 per cent students of the state board,”he said. Chavan said the very purpose of the NEET is to
      reduce the number of examinations. The State CET
      is conducted for admission to medical, dental,
      Ayurved, Unani, nursing courses among others and
      for engineering courses. Conducting NEET will not avoid the state CET
      because through NEET, engineering admissions can
      not be done as there is no Mathematics paper in the
      NEET. Students from the state will have to appear with
      NCERT syllabus for NEET (UG) 2012 and at the same
      time with the state board syllabus for the
      Maharashtra CET for engineering and other
      admissions. This will create more burden on the
      students, Chavan added. He urged the union health minister to exempt
      Maharashtra from NEET (UG) 2012. “Our state would
      like to join the NEET from 2013,” Chavan said.

  10. TO ALL PRO NEET PEOPLES
    DON’T THINK THAT YOU ARE THE MOST INTELLIGENT PEOPLE HERE ….. YOU ALL KEEP WRITING ABOUT MERIT AND CORRUPTION BUT FAIL TO EXPLAIN HOW NEET IS REDUCING CORRUPTION ………. PUT SOME VALID REASONS AND THEN TALK .
    IT IS QUITE SURPRISING TO SEE HOW THOSE 2-3 NEET SUPPORTES ARE CHANGING THEIR NAMES AND WRITING COMMENTS …………..

    • GAMER BHAI JUST READ YOUR COMMENTS TO ALL SUPPORTERS …. YOU ARE AT YOUR BEST TODAY ………. SALE SOUTH INDIAN TO EXEMPT HO JAYENGE AUR INKI KARNI KI SAJHA HUM BHUGTE GE……… YAHAN TO KUCH LOG MCI TAK JANE KA PROGRAM BANA RAHE HAIN ……..

      WAISE TO MAIN BLOG PAR GALI DENA PASAND NAHI KARTA PAR AB SALA MAN KAR RAHA HAI JITNI ATI HAI UTNI LIKHDO MCI KO BHI AUR SUPPORTERS KO BHI ………….

  11. @swathi s since you are not prepared now u can take the exam in 2014. For just 1 person like you the rest lakhs of students should not suffer. Bring on neet in 2012. We want it badly. Those who are not prepared can take it in 2012.

    • @ kanika
      lakhs of students are facing problems because of few ignorant idiots like u kanika …. you are most welcome to write exam in 2014 but don’t advice this to others ………… if you are preparing for neet it should not matter to you weather neet is conducted or aipmt cause portion is the same ……….
      just for once give some solid reason why you are so desperate in bringing neet in 2012………

      • HELLO MR. SAR
        STOP PRAISING OTHERS AND FIRST YOU TELL ME HOW NEET IS BENEFITIG PEOPLE … HOPE FOR A CHANGE YOU WILL BE ABLE TO PUT SOME GOOD REASONS……..

  12. THIS IS A CRYSTAL CLEAR REPORT WHY NEET IS BEING OPPOSED BY SOME STATES. THE CRUX OF THE MATTER IS THAT ALL THESE POLITICIANS ARE CORRUPT AND FOR GETTING MONEY FROM THE PRIVATE COLLEGE MGMTS, THEY STOOP TO THE LEVEL OF BETRAYING THEIR OWN PEOPLE & MERITED STUDENTS. UNFORTUNATELY, SOME STUDENTS ARE MISLEAD AND MAKE TO BELIEVE THAT NEET WOULD BE HARMFUL TO THEM ALSO. NEET IS A BOON AND BLESSING IN DISGUISE TO ALL STUDENTS.
    ====================================================================
    Report in DC 22/11/2011 “Volte-Face on Entrance Test.

    It was the BJP government in Karnataka that proposed the single entrance test for medical admission three years ago following complaints that multiple exams for entrance to the medical course created unnecessary pressure on students. But now, the state has changed its mind and has decided to oppose the single National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET)-Under Graduate (UG), proposed by the Medical Council of India (MCI) for admission to the MBBS course. The reason for the volte face is said to be pressure from private colleges who make a pretty penny out of the present system.

    Most of the medical colleges in the state are owned by people close political heavy weights, and they fear their colleges will incur heavy losses if MCI scraps the multiple admission tests. Following pressure from students and parents, MCI decided to introduce the NEET-UG last year, but deferred it by a year following requests form several States, including Karnataka, that they needed time to implement the test.

    But now the State government has decided to oppose the NEET-UG and approach the Supreme Court in this regard. According to sources in the medical education department, the decision to oppose the NEET-UG has been taken at a time when the Karnataka Examination Authority (KEA) is all set to launch a special coaching programme for candidates applying for medial colleges in the State. is this for NEET? They attribute the sudden change in the decision to pressure from private medical colleges. Not clear how the coaching classes and the pressure from private colleges are related. If they are not then delete para

    It is obvious from the sequence of events that extraneous influences are behind the change in the government’s stand. Speaking to this newspaper, a senior officer of the medical education department said that on November 16, higher education minister Dr V.S. Acharya himself praised the concept of NEET-UG at a KEA meeting and had suggested that a special training programme for State students be launched to ensure a level playing field. Medical Education Minister S.A. Ramadas, who was present at the meeting, endorsed Dr Acharya’s opinion. But two days later, Dr Acharya was forced to backtrack.

    “When MCI requested the States to send feedback to the draft NEET-UG curriculum in the month of August, the State government as well as the RGUHS did not respond. Now government is using the same to defend its opposition to the NEET-UG. If the State government was serious about implementing NEET-UG it would have sent its feed back to the draft curriculum,” stated a senior officer of the medical education department.

    Should MCI go ahead with the NEET-UG, private colleges and deemed universities fear huge revenue losses because, not surprisingly, graft is at the bottom of this system like all others. “Presently seats are blocked and sold in private colleges. Malpractice is common in the admission tests. Every seat is fetching more than Rs 1 crore to the college management. So, no one wants reforms in the admission test,” the official quoted above explained.
    =====================================================================

  13. Dear sir,
    Eventhough the process of uniform cet is beneficial to medical study aspirants,it will workout correctly if it is started from the year 2014,so that all states can adopt central syllabus from 2012-13.Otherwise students who study under state syllabus will suffer.

  14. funny to see ppl call themself true indian n r afraid to giv an xam whch has slightly more content…haha lolzz
    its a pity to knw dat d country is filld with COWARDS!!!!
    BOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!”

    • FUNNY HUH . HOW ARE U COMPARING THE PATRIOTISM OF ONE PERSON TO HIS NATION WITH WRITING AN EXAM ……… I AM DAMN SURE U ARE SCARED TO FACE THE STATE STUDENTS IN STATE PMT AND SO IS YELLING ON THIS FORUM ……….. BUT STOP BEING SUCH SINGLE MINDED PERSON …….. YOU ARE A SELFISH PERSON TO CALL OTHERS COWARD ……… TAKE THAT BOO AND INSERT IT IN YOUR ASS……….

  15. i am still shocked that no decision has come yet ………. it surprises me that still some though handfull are supprting neet …….

    never mind neet will cancel this year ….. i mean november is about to end and cbse will also be bringing aipmt notification ……..

  16. mci should have shame that they are doing such a thing ….. our states are most backward …….. we don’t even get proper schooling facilities to compete at national level ……… already this year we have been worst hit by blockade ……… no one is thinking about us ……… our govt. is puppet of sonia gandhi (bitch).
    neet not possible and should not be possible this year …………

    • Shut up you idiot no one is backward nowadays. I am from meghalaya which u fools call most backward but we are equally advanced. The central govt is doing much worj for our uplifting. I think you r living in the 80’s with such mindset. We want neet so that munnabhais like you should be barred from noble career like medicine. Tell us from which college you have booked your seat & how much have you paid the minister to buy your seat.

        • YOU MAY BE PRIVLEGED TO STUDY IN GOOD SCHOOLS AND IN DEVELOP[ED AREAS BUT NOT ALL ARE SO STOP YOUR SINGLE MINDED THINKING …….

      • VALENTINE YOUR COMMENT ITSELF SUGGEST YOU ARE NOT FROM MEGHALAYA ….. HAVE YOU HEARD ABOUT THE 93 DAY BLOCKAIDE THAT TOOK PLACE THIS YEAR …. I DON’T SUPPOSE IGNORANT PERSON LIKE U WILL HEAR ALL THESE ……… TYHE COMMENTS U HAVE WRITTEN IS ACTUALLY WRITTEN BY ONLY TWO PEOPLE ON THIS SITE ……. I WON’T TAKE THE NAME BUT WHEN THEY WILL READ THEY WILL DEFINATELY REALISE ………. HAD THESE STATES BEEN DEVELOPED THEN SO MANY FREEDON MOVEMENTS TAKING PLACE IN THESE AREAS WOULD NOT HAVE TAKEN PLACE ……… INDIA IS COUNTRY WHERE STILL MORE THAN 100 FREEDOM MOVEMENTS TAKE PLACE . THIS ITSELF SHOWS HOW DEVELOPED WE ARE…..

  17. Most logical thing for MCI to do is to announce that NEET will be held in 2014, through proper channels to ensure all concerned get the information.With such an advance notice,there can not be any opposition.Govt.on it’s part should ensure that syllabus is made common to sort out the problem of uneven playing field.Third issue of language can be resolved by allowing regional language papers for initial period of 2 or 3 years and then withdraw gradually.

  18. sub ko pani apani student ka koi sochata nahi hai. Jo student regional languege me padhata hai vo kaise english or hindi me exam deke rank me a sakta. neet ka area acha hai leking do bat ka dhyan rakhan sahie.
    1 Neet all constitutional languge me leni chahiye.
    2 Ek common silabus banake sabhi state boards ko naya ssylabus banake 2012-13 se 11th me impliment karke NEET 2014-15 se lagu karni shahiye. Eske liye abhi se taiyari karani chahiye.

    • dude i can understand abt eng
      but if u r an indian n dont knw hindi then thatz sumthng highly unacceptable!!!
      afterall every state me dono me se ek language toh garaunteed padhaya jaata hai. .:/

  19. THANKS FOR SPEEDY UPDATE. DONT KNOW WHY THE CENTRAL HEALTH MINISTRY IS COOLING THEIR HEELS ON THE MATTER…EITHER THEY SHOULD SAY YES OR NO TO MCI PROPOSAL OF N.E.E.T FROM 2012. JUST CREATING TENSION ALL AROUND.

  20. @ srikanth…
    Plz correct this line

    Although MCI was desperate of holding NEET UG on May 13, 2011,
    Its 2012 and not 2011…
    Thank u…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


9 × nine =

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>